Follow us on Instagram
Try our free mini crossword
Subscribe to the newsletter
Download the app

Ibish criticizes administration's Iraq policy

Hussein Ibish, Communications Director for the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, blasted the Bush administration for what he called a "neo-conservative" doctrine that led to the "total mismanagement" of the Iraqi situation in a lecture in the Frist Campus Center this weekend.

Ibish said "an incredible burden has been placed" on the United States by "the superimposition of a preexisting . . . vision of how to use American power in the world."

ADVERTISEMENT

Ibish described the ADC as a "national grassroots organization" dedicated to the civil rights of Arabs in the United States and the Middle East. He has worked with the ADC for more than a decade, promoting awareness of Arabic issues through numerous newspaper submissions and thousands of radio and television appearances.

The chief division in the United States government is not between Democrats and Republicans, Ibish said, but between three nonpartisan "factions" — neo-conservatives who seek change, conservative realists who seek the status quo and liberals who also seek the status quo but have "a desire that the United States should not only be respected and feared, but liked."

Ibish called the neo-conservative branch "the smallest but the most potent." Its ability to follow a "clear, defined vision," he said, allows it to have a "disproportionate [governmental] influence."

Yet he called this vision an "ideological fantasy" that prompts neo-conservatives to "frame planning around a belief system rather than reality," resulting in "extraordinary mistakes in methods of dealing with Iraq."

One such mistake was governmental lack of interest in accurately projecting the Iraq war's real costs, Ibish said.

"Americans will be taxed [both] financially and in terms of manpower," he said, contrasting early financial projections with "a $187 billion bill, which is actually just a down payment on what [the Iraq war] will cost in the end."

ADVERTISEMENT
Tiger hand holding out heart
Support nonprofit student journalism. Donate to the ‘Prince’. Donate now »

He said the notion that Iraqis would immediately embrace American occupation also led the government to underestimate the manpower needed in Iraq.

"Rumsfeld assured Congress at this time last year that we wouldn't need more than 30,000 [soldiers in Iraq]," Ibish said. There are now over 200,000, he added.

Ibish also said the government made overoptimistic predictions of Iraqi reaction to American occupation.

Hussein said it would be predictable for Iraqis to be relieved to be "unburdened" of Hussein, though he said he can also see "the occupation is increasingly linked [by Iraqis] with everything that goes wrong."

Subscribe
Get the best of the ‘Prince’ delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe now »

Ibish said the Bush administration is not only overlooking the realities of the Iraq situation, but is in danger of doing so elsewhere.

"We're talking about a foreign policy agenda that emphasizes American preeminence in all its forms, both globally and regionally . . . underwritten by [irrational devotion to] preemptive war."