Reader Comments

A failing grade for the P/D/F policy

Written by Adam Bradlow, Columnist
Published: Wednesday, February 27th, 2008
Now in the midst of our fourth week of the semester and nearly two weeks past the deadline for altering our schedules, most students are finally locked into their course selections. Therefore, it is at around this time of year ...(back to the article)

Viewing 5 comments...

  • 1.
    1:58 a.m. on Feb. 28th, 2008
    Posted by Are You Kidding

    Dear Get Real: Are you even a student here? Lighter course load? Easy? You can't be serious.

    Current Rating: 0 (0 Ups and 0 Downs)
    Thumbs Up!  Thumbs Down!
  • 2.
    11:50 p.m. on Feb. 27th, 2008
    Posted by Stop Whining

    Do you realize the implications of removing the limit of 4 PDFs and allowing rescinded PDFs not to count against your total? Well, if that were the case, I'd PDF every single class every single semester and rescind all of them by week 9 except for the classes in which I'm not getting A's. Also, if you let people see their grade at the end of the semester and then choose whether or not to rescind a PDF, then every P on my transcript would signify a class in which I received a grade below my cumulative average. Basically, in both cases, the value of the P grade would be eroded since it would clearly signify a class in which a student performed poorly. Whereas under the current policy, while a P probably does not represent an A range grade, it is possible that it did. Besides, if you really want to explore something that you'd potentially be interested in majoring in, you should be committed to doing the work. PDFing a class usually isn't conducive to that. Finally, Princeton already has a very generous drop policy compared to a lot of other institutions. If you really need to explore and want a way out in case you find that a class isn't your cup of tea, just take an extra class and drop the class if you find you aren't doing so well in it. It's that simple.

    Current Rating: 0 (0 Ups and 0 Downs)
    Thumbs Up!  Thumbs Down!
  • 3.
    11:33 p.m. on Feb. 27th, 2008
    Posted by Get Real

    Just because a course or field may not be your "cup of tea" doesn't mean you can't work hard and receive a decent grade. It may not be the A you're hoping for, but I truly doubt an honest try and a good deal of elbow grease will result in a grade lower than a C. In comparison to many undergraduate institutions, where a full load of courses requires students to take FIVE rather than FOUR at a time, Princeton undergrads already have it easy. It's hard to fathom the entitlement that demands, in addition to a lighter course load, a more generous P/D/F policy.

    Current Rating: 0 (0 Ups and 0 Downs)
    Thumbs Up!  Thumbs Down!
  • 4.
    3:40 p.m. on Feb. 27th, 2008
    Posted by We're Workin' On It

    In fact, the USG has and is continuing to work with administrators on P/D/F reform by voicing students' concerns while brainstorming possible solutions.

    Current Rating: 0 (0 Ups and 0 Downs)
    Thumbs Up!  Thumbs Down!
  • 5.
    12:17 p.m. on Feb. 27th, 2008
    Posted by Yes

    I agree, especially with the first part.

    Current Rating: 0 (0 Ups and 0 Downs)
    Thumbs Up!  Thumbs Down!

Post your comments on this article

Comments:

:

Captcha

For security reasons, please enter the word in the image above.

 


< Back to the article


The opinions expressed here are those of the individual commenters and do not necessarily represent the views of The Daily Princetonian Publishing Company, Inc. We do not take responsibility for the opinions, facts, or claims presented by individual commenters, and reserve the right to moderate or delete inappropriate comments.